In my experience over many years as an insolvency practitioner, one of the hardest conversations to have is the one about when to stop. Many directors run right up to, or past, the point at which trading further becomes reckless or wrongful. The difference between a decision being prudent and one being a liability often comes down to timing, judgement, and evidence.
In this post I’ll draw on practical experience to help you recognise the red‑lines, act early, and minimise personal exposure. I’ll share tips, cautionary signals I’ve seen in real cases, and a tidy checklist you can carry into boardrooms.
Why Waiting Can Be Riskier Than Acting
Before a company enters formal insolvency, there is a ‘zone’ (sometimes called the ‘twilight zone’) when liabilities are mounting and prospects are deteriorating. The Supreme Court’s decision in BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA confirmed that directors’ duty to consider creditors’ interests is triggered when insolvency becomes imminent or when insolvent liquidation or administration become probable.
If you wait until the business is unambiguously insolvent, your room to manoeuvre narrows dramatically. Wrongful trading, preference claims, and disqualification risk all become acute.
From my practice, the common trap is this: directors hold on hoping for a last push – new orders, a rescue offer, a cash injection – only to find that decisions made in the final stretch can’t be justified later.
Key Warning Signals You Can’t Ignore
Based on my 40 years in the field, here are red flags I’ve seen repeatedly:
| Warning Signal | What It Often Indicates | What To Do Immediately |
|---|---|---|
| Persistent cashflow shortfalls, even after cost-cutting | The business is no longer solving underlying issues | Reforecast aggressively; stress‑test every scenario |
| Failure to collect receivables, rising bad/deferred debts | Credit control has broken down | Tighten collection, review credit policies, challenge write-offs |
| Repeated breaches of banking covenants | Liquidity constraints and lender pressure | Negotiate with banks early; explore forbearance |
| Major creditor pressure or threats of winding-up notices | Creditor confidence is evaporating | Engage advisers, review risk of escalation |
| Lack of up-to-date management accounts | You’re flying blind | Insist on timely numbers; stop trading until you have clarity |
These are the signals. What’s more important is acting while you still can – not when the accident has already happened.
What You Should Do Before Formal Insolvency
-
Reassess viability with fresh challenge
Bring in an external view. Your accountant or adviser should stress-test your scenario. Be willing to kill ideas with no upside. -
Document every decision, every justification
Keep board minutes, written memos, and contemporaneous notes. If you later need to explain decisions, the evidence matters more than the outcome. -
Suspend or restructure high-cost contracts
If leases, supply agreements or overheads weigh you down, see if you can renegotiate or exit without further loss. -
Avoid preferential payments
Don’t repay shareholders or connected parties if other creditors remain unpaid. The liquidator may claw these back. -
Limit new credit and avoid taking deposits you can’t deliver against
Promising deliverables you can’t honour can amount to wrongful or misfeasance. -
Communicate with key creditors (with caution)
You don’t need to surrender your negotiating position, but silence can be worse than disclosure. If you can propose a path forward (e.g. via a CVA) that gives realism and confidence, it can buy you time. -
Engage a licensed insolvency practitioner early
It’s better to have options while you still have choices. Waiting until things collapse dramatically reduces your leverage.
From Signals to Action: A Real‑Life Moment
In one case I handled, the directors had ignored client demand falling away, slow debtor collections, and overdraft breaches. They held on hoping a large order would turn things around. By the time the order arrived, it came with onerous penalties. The directors were left defending continued trading right up to the edge – and ultimately found themselves in wrongful trading proceedings. Had they paused earlier and assessed more conservatively, they might have rescued value, protected creditors, and avoided protracted investigations.
That’s not hypothetical. It’s the kind of situation that repeats again and again across the insolvency landscape.
Takeaway Checklist
-
Regularly review cashflow, balance sheet, and debtor trends
-
Compare forecasts to worst‑case scenarios
-
Demand timely management accounts (ideally at least monthly)
-
Suspend preferential payments and related‑party transactions
-
Avoid promising new deliverables without certainty
-
Document board discussions and the reasoning behind choices
-
Seek independent advice (accountant or IP) while there is still time
-
Communicate (selectively) with key creditors or stakeholders
-
Evaluate whether formal procedures (administration, CVA) are viable before it’s too late
-
If formal insolvency becomes necessary, cooperate fully with the office-holder